I never read a Harry Potter book until this year. My parents didn't allow me to read them, and I wanted to respect their wishes. However, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone was required reading for my adolescent literature class this fall, and I decided I'd read the whole series after that one. (Plus one of my best friends kind of pressured me into reading them. She's such a bad influence.) Anyways, I wrote my second take-home essay on the topic shared in the post title. And now I'm going to share my essay with y'all.
Many Christian parents will not allow
their children to read the Harry Potter series,
simply because the books feature wizards, witches, and magic. They
believe the series is in direct contradiction to the Bible, which in several
instances in the Old and New Testaments, condemns witchcraft. For
example, in Galatians 5:19-21, Paul says, “The acts of the sinful nature are
obvious: sexual immorality, impurity, and debauchery; idolatry and witchcraft;
hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions,
factions, and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn
you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the
kingdom of God.” However, there are also many Christians who believe the Harry Potter books are acceptable to
read and are not contrary to God’s Word. In fact, there are reasons why the books
not only can be read but also should be read by preteens and teenagers.
Readers must acknowledge that the Bible lists
witchcraft as a sin; however, the two kinds of witchcraft—that of the Bible and
that of J.K. Rowling’s book series—seem to be quite
different. The former is used only for evil, for contact with Satan
and his demons and to carry out Satan’s orders; the latter, in the hands of the
right people, is used for practical daily life as well as for good. Harry
Potter, Hermione Granger, and Ron Weasley, among many of the wizards and
witches in the series, use magic to protect the innocent, stop the forces of
evil, and save the wizarding world. Of course there are wizards who use
magic for evil, such as Lord Voldemort and Bellatrix Lestrange, but they are
shown to be in the wrong time after time.
The Harry
Potter books also teach many valuable moral lessons. First
and foremost is the lesson of good prevailing over evil. Early
in the first book, Harry Potter and the
Sorcerer’s Stone, Harry learns about the existence of Lord Voldemort, a
dark wizard who murdered Harry’s mother and father.
Voldemort tried to take over the wizarding world 11 years prior, but the powers
of good prevailed. Harry learns why Voldemort is so bad—he hates Muggleborn
students, uses the Unforgivable Curses (curses that control, torture, and kill)
with reckless abandon, and craves power so he can dominate others. In
contrast, Harry befriends anyone who is kind, no matter if he or she is a
pureblood wizard or Muggleborn; only uses the Unforgivable Curses when he has
no choice; and does not desire to be the Chosen One.
Harry
Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone
also teaches the value of friendship. Harry, Hermione, and Ron learn to depend
on each other, and each young wizard or witch has strengths that balance out his
or her friends’ weaknesses. The three are considered one of
literature’s golden trios because they are stronger together and so iconic. Later
on in the series, Harry also befriends Luna Lovegood, a girl who is a bit of an
outcast because she is eccentric and dreamy. Rowling uses all of her younger
characters to prove that friendship can win wars, as so many wizards and
witches stand beside Harry in the Battle of Hogwarts because of the kindness
and courage he demonstrated.
Also important in the Harry Potter series are the Christian
values of courage and sacrifice. Harry must be brave on several
occasions, but it is Neville Longbottom, who stands up to his friends when they
break the rules, who could be to said to be the bravest of them all. In
fact, thanks to his courage, Professor Dumbledore awards Gryffindor ten extra
points, thereby winning Gryffindor the House Cup. Throughout the series, Harry and others
sacrifice themselves for the greater good. In Harry
Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Ron sacrifices himself in the game of
chess so Hermione and Harry can go forward and stop Professor Quirrell and
Voldemort. Later on, in the third book, Ron has broken his leg, and
yet he tells Sirius Black that Sirius will have to go through him and Hermione
to get to Harry. Throughout the series, many of the good wizards and witches
exhibit courage and sacrifice much to save their world.
Finally, many Christian parents allow—and
often encourage—their children to read The
Chronicles of Narnia and Lord of the
Rings series. Both of these series feature witches, wizards, and magic. So what
makes them different from the Harry
Potter series? Perhaps it is the Christian intent with which C.S. Lewis
and J.R.R. Tolkien
wrote their books, but all three series teach the difference between good and
evil, as well as the values of friendship, courage, and sacrifice, among many
others.
Therefore, it is clear why the Harry Potter series not only acceptable
but should be promoted for Christians to read. Most children, if properly communicated
with during and after they read the books, will understand that Hogwarts and
the wizards are part of a fictional world. They will understand why the witchcraft
of our world is evil and contrary to God’s Word. Perhaps they will even learn important
lessons from Harry Potter and his friends.
If you're a Christian, have you read Harry Potter? Why or why not?
I know I haven't commented on your blog in a LONG time, but I thought that this would be an good time to do it, since I just finished the whole HP series for the first time.
ReplyDeleteI grew up with the same thing. My parents didn't want me reading them, and they were the taboo books for a long time, until my brother read them when he was about 16.
I'm 17 and I just read them, and they were good. My mom's main objections were that, the witches are portrayed as the good guys, instead of getting defeated like in Narnia or LotR, and she didn't like how the Muggles were represented (I think that she thought that Muggles were supposed to be mocking Christians).
When the first book came out, my oldest brother was in first grade (I think) and I'm pretty sure that his teachers were suggesting that all the kids read it, or have their parents read it with them. That was when my parents read the first one and decided that it wasn't a good idea for a 7 year old.
I like your take on it. I mean, those were the things that popped out to me the most to recommend the series. I like the theme of sacrifice, and I liked how Dumbledore wasn't perfect, and a bunch of other things. At the same time, I can see why my parents didn't want an impressionable 7 year old reading them.
Those are basically my feelings on it. I'm glad that I read them when I did, and I really enjoyed them, and I'll be glad to read them with my kids, as long as they're old enough. :)
~D. Skye
Oh, I definitely agree that elementary school might be a bit young for the books. If I have children, I'll let them read the first three books when they're about 10 or 11 and then they'll need to wait until they're 13 or in high school for the rest of the series, since book 4 is where things take a bit of a dark turn.
Delete